Skip to content

Every index compared: what trade and area actually explain

Each Local Digital Visibility Index covers one trade in one town, and until now they could only be read one at a time. There are 34 of them: 1371 businesses across 11 trades and 8 towns, all scored the same way.

This page reads them together. Every figure is computed from the published datasets when the page is built.

IndexTownTradeFirmsMedian score
Exeter SolicitorExetersolicitors867.5
Cheltenham Law FirmCheltenhamlaw firms865.5
Swindon Estate AgentSwindonestate agents865
Bath Estate AgentBathestate agents1562
Bristol DentistBristoldentists961
Swindon VetSwindonveterinary practices1759
Worcester VetWorcesterveterinary practices1558
Bristol VetBristolveterinary practices2957
Bristol Estate AgentBristolestate agents1856
Cheltenham VetCheltenhamveterinary practices2056
Worcester ArchitectWorcesterarchitects2554
Cheltenham PhysiotherapyCheltenhamphysiotherapy clinics6853
Exeter PhysiotherapyExeterphysiotherapy clinics5353
Gloucester PhysiotherapyGloucesterphysiotherapy clinics4653
Bristol PhysiotherapyBristolphysiotherapy clinics6252
Exeter ArchitectExeterarchitects6352
Exeter VetExeterveterinary practices2152
Gloucester AccountantGloucesteraccountants4152
Gloucester VetGloucesterveterinary practices2152
Bath VetBathveterinary practices1051.5
Bath PhysiotherapyBathphysiotherapy clinics6751
Bristol Double GlazingBristoldouble glazing companies11651
Cheltenham ArchitectCheltenhamarchitects5951
Bath ArchitectBatharchitects8050.5
Swindon PhysiotherapySwindonphysiotherapy clinics4050.5
Gloucester ConstructionGloucesterconstruction firms1350
Gloucester RestaurantGloucesterrestaurants4450
Gloucestershire Double GlazingGloucestershiredouble glazing companies9950
Swindon ArchitectSwindonarchitects2950
Worcester ConstructionWorcesterconstruction firms5549
Worcester PhysiotherapyWorcesterphysiotherapy clinics4549
Bristol ArchitectBristolarchitects8048
Gloucester ArchitectGloucesterarchitects3548
Cheltenham ConstructionCheltenhamconstruction firms5246

The spread runs from 67.5 (Exeter Solicitor) to 46 (Cheltenham Construction), against a pooled median of 52.

Before reading anything into that order: the cohorts are very uneven. The largest holds 116 businesses and the smallest 8. A median drawn from eight firms moves if two of them change.

The obvious question, and the data answers it in a way that undercuts both options.

Share of the variation in Digital Visibility Score explained by each factor, across 1371 businesses. Sector and town overlap, so the first two do not add up.
  • Which trade you are in
    11 sectors
    8.9%
  • Which town you are in
    8 towns
    1.2%
  • Both together
    34 cohorts
    11.2%
  • Everything else
    differences between businesses in the same trade and town
    88.8%

Trade explains 8.9% of the variation between businesses. Town explains 1.2%. Both together explain 11.2%.

Which leaves 88.8% — about seven eighths — as differences between businesses in the same trade in the same area.

That is the most useful finding on this page. The two explanations a business reaches for first, everyone in my trade is like this and it’s harder here, together account for 11.2% of what separates the best from the worst. Most of the difference is between you and the firm down the road doing the same job in the same place.

That share got larger, not smaller, when the index tripled in size. On eleven indices trade and area explained about a third; on 34 they explain 11.2%. Adding three trades and 885 businesses did not reveal a trade effect that the smaller sample had hidden.

Some trades appear in more than one area, and some areas hold more than one trade, which lets the two be separated a little.

Same trade, different areasAreasIndex mediansSpread
estate agents356 · 62 · 659
veterinary practices751.5 · 52 · 52 · 56 · 57 · 58 · 597.5
architects748 · 48 · 50 · 50.5 · 51 · 52 · 546
physiotherapy clinics749 · 50.5 · 51 · 52 · 53 · 53 · 534
construction firms346 · 49 · 504
double glazing companies250 · 511
Same area, different tradesTradesIndex mediansSpread
Cheltenham546 · 51 · 53 · 56 · 65.519.5
Exeter452 · 52 · 53 · 67.515.5
Swindon450 · 50.5 · 59 · 6515
Bristol648 · 51 · 52 · 56 · 57 · 6113
Bath450.5 · 51 · 51.5 · 6211.5
Worcester449 · 49 · 54 · 589
Gloucester648 · 50 · 50 · 52 · 52 · 535

Physiotherapy clinics sit between 49 and 53 across all 7 areas they are measured in, a spread of 4 points — the trade travels with the firms. Estate agents vary more than twice as widely by area, 9 points. And the single widest gap anywhere is within one town: Cheltenham, where 5 trades sit 19.5 points apart on the same streets.

Median pillar score for each trade, across 1371 businesses. Read a row for what a sector looks like; read a column for whether that pillar tells trades apart at all.
SectorFirmsSpeed & CWVTechnicalLocal presenceVisibilityAI search presenceContent & trustScore
solicitors87510078312078.567.5
law firms878.5888238108365.5
estate agents4168758518207061
dentists964888425207061
veterinary practices133698878206255
physiotherapy clinics38166.58875405452
accountants41697579405552
architects371677576004151
double glazing companies215668874004150
restaurants44757586.5002950
construction firms12064.57576003749

Cohorts are uneven — 8 businesses in the smallest, 381 in the largest — so a median from a small trade moves on a few firms. Local presence carries a known sector effect and is the one column to read with most caution.

Read the columns rather than the rows and the point arrives immediately.

Local presence varies by only 12.5 points between the best and worst trade, and it carries 20% of every score. The other pillars measuring the website itself are nearly as flat. Every trade has broadly the same website quality.

Content & trust varies by 54 points. So do the other two pillars about publishing and being found. The trades at the top of the table publish things and appear in results; the trades at the bottom have comparable websites and are invisible.

Restaurants are the clearest case. They top the table on Local presence — busy Google profiles, plenty of reviews — and sit last on content, with a median search visibility of zero. A restaurant is findable on a map and absent from a search. Architects and construction firms share that zero, from much weaker Google profiles.

The design is unbalanced and observational. Not every trade appears in every town, cohorts run from 8 to 116 firms, and the trades were not chosen at random. The variance shares above describe the businesses we measured; they are not estimates about UK business in general.

Trade and town are entangled. Because the coverage is incomplete, some of what is attributed to trade is really town and the reverse. That is why both figures are reported separately and the two are not added together.

Local presence deserves particular caution. That pillar includes review velocity, which is substantially a property of a trade rather than of a business. Comparing it across sectors compares review cultures.

A few months of data is not a pattern. Every figure here comes from the latest release, and each new release is a further test. The sensible use of this page is to check afterwards which of these relationships survived.

If you run one of these businesses, the ranking of trades is the least useful thing here. The useful part is the 88.8%.

Your trade and your town set the conditions. They do not set your score. 88.8% of what separates the best firm in your index from the worst is neither, and on the evidence of the fingerprint above it is concentrated in whether you have published anything worth finding.

The scorecard for your own business names the specific faults, and the Digital Visibility Score page explains what the number is made of.